CostToReno

Home / Guides

Guide ยท reviewed November 2026

Asphalt vs metal roof cost: what the upgrade really costs

Asphalt shingles are the common choice for roof replacement. Metal costs a lot more up front. Here are the published ranges side by side.

What published guides report

  • Asphalt shingles: $4.25 to $12.25 per square foot, the range used in the calculator.
  • Metal: $10 to $35 per square foot, the range used in the calculator.
  • Asphalt replacement average (This Old House): $5,800 to $12,200, with metal at twice as much or more.
  • Overall (NerdWallet): a general rule of $4 to $11 per square foot, about $6,000 to $16,500 for 1,500 square feet and $8,000 to $22,000 for 2,000 square feet.
  • Average total (Angi, quoted by NerdWallet): about $9,500, in a range from about $5,800 to $46,000.

A worked example

For an 1,800 square foot roof, asphalt at $4.25 to $12.25 comes to $7,650 to $22,050. Metal at $10 to $35 comes to $18,000 to $63,000. The wide spread is real: metal type, roof shape and region all move the price.

How we calculated this

We multiplied each per foot range by 1,800 square feet and kept low and high separate. The ranges are wide because they cover several product grades. We did not average them, and we did not add tear off, which is often priced as a separate line.

Where prices differ from these ranges

  • Steep, complex roofs with valleys and dormers cost more per square foot.
  • Tear off, decking repair and underlayment are often extra.
  • Metal spans $10 to $35 per square foot, so the exact product matters a lot.
  • Local labor rates and permit rules change the final bid.

Questions to ask a contractor

  • Does the price include tear off and disposal of the old roof?
  • Is any decking repair included, and how is extra rot priced?
  • What brand, grade and warranty does this quote use?
  • Is the permit and inspection fee in the price?

Run your numbers

Open the roof replacement calculator, enter your roof area and material, and compare the range with your quotes.

Sources